Stressed law firm owner at a desk in December realizing year-end financial deadlines have already passed

Why Waiting Until December Is Too Late

Waiting until December is too late because several of a law firm’s most valuable year-end decisions need lead time that December doesn’t have. The retirement plan question, equipment timing, settlement timing, partner distributions, and the planning conversation with your CPA all work best in October and November. By December, most of them have narrowed to execution, and some have closed entirely.

If you’re reading this in late October, you mostly still have time. That’s the good news. The catch is that “still have time” usually means four to six weeks, not “whenever things calm down.” We covered why year-end keeps landing this way in Why Year-End Always Feels Chaotic. This post is about what that pattern actually costs.

Which financial decisions can a law firm still make in October, and which have already closed?

Some windows are already gone, and the open ones are closing on a schedule. A few examples worth raising with your CPA this month:

Retirement plans

For a firm that doesn’t already have a SIMPLE IRA, the window to set one up for 2026 generally closed on October 1. Other plan types and plan changes have their own deadlines, and some of those depend on your plan documents. The point isn’t that you missed something. It’s that retirement plan options have dates attached, and your CPA can tell you which ones still apply to your firm.

Equipment and technology purchases

Equipment generally has to be placed in service by December 31 to count for the current tax year. Ordered isn’t the same as placed in service. If the firm is considering new hardware, case management software, or office buildout, that needs a November decision to have a December finish. Ask your CPA what qualifies for your situation.

Distributions and bonuses

This one is still fully open, but only if someone builds the model in November. More on that below.

Why does waiting until December cost law firms more than they expect?

Because the costs don’t arrive in December. They arrive in March and April, all at once, when nothing can be changed.

Brooke Lively, Cathcap’s founder, described the pattern in her Attorney at Work column: “Lawyers are often caught off guard when the accountant comes to them in March or April and says, ‘You owe $$$$.'” The question that follows is always the same: how can I owe money if there was barely any cash left in the account at year-end?

For a contingency firm, the answer is usually a stack of things nobody connected in the fall. A big settlement landed in Q4 and nobody adjusted the estimated payments. A December bonus was paid out of cash the firm needed for January payroll and taxes. The retirement plan conversation never happened. And by the time the CPA was available to talk about any of it, the year was closed.

None of those were bad decisions. They were decisions made by default, because no one flagged the window while it was open.

How does a contingency fee firm’s settlement timing affect year-end financial planning?

Most PI and plaintiff firms report on a cash basis, so fee income generally counts in the year the settlement clears and the fee is disbursed. A large case that clears in late December lands in 2026. The same case clearing in early January lands in 2027.

That doesn’t mean an owner can simply pick the date. The rules around when income is considered received are technical and specific to your situation, and that’s a conversation for your CPA. But your CPA can only advise on a settlement they know is coming. That’s why the October case pipeline review matters: which matters are realistically likely to settle in Q4, and roughly how large are they?

The CFO’s job is to surface the question. The CPA’s job is to answer it. If nobody surfaces it before the check clears, the decision gets made for you. To have that conversation with confidence, the books underneath it need to be current, which is what What Clean Financials Actually Mean lays out.

When is the right time for a law firm to have the year-end conversation with their CPA?

October through November. That’s when your CPA still has room to plan with you. By January they’re preparing returns. From February through mid-April, they’re filing. Whatever you didn’t decide in the fall shows up in their work as a result, not as an option.

The best version of that meeting doesn’t start with questions. It starts with a package: current financials, a short list of Q4 cases likely to settle, a modeled distribution scenario, the open retirement plan question, and any equipment decisions on the table. How to Prepare for Year-End Before It’s Urgent walks through how to put that together in October and November.

An owner who walks in with that package gets advice. An owner who walks in empty-handed in February gets a bill.

What does a law firm lose by starting year-end planning in December instead of October?

  1. Retirement plan options with fall deadlines, like setting up a new SIMPLE IRA for the current year.
  2. The lead time to get equipment placed in service by December 31, rather than just ordered.
  3. A settlement timing conversation with the CPA before Q4 checks clear trust.
  4. A distribution decision based on a November close, instead of a December estimate made under pressure.
  5. Your CPA’s planning availability, before busy season takes over their calendar.
  6. A 2027 Profit Plan ready by January 1, so the new year starts with targets instead of cleanup.

Every item on that list depends on a PI firm’s specific structure: lumpy settlement income, cash-basis timing, and trust accounts that have to be reconciled before anyone can say with confidence what’s safe to distribute.

What to Do Next

  1. List the cases your attorneys believe are likely to settle before December 31.
  2. Ask your CPA which retirement plan and equipment decisions are still open for 2026, and by when.
  3. Schedule a November planning meeting with your CPA now, before their calendar fills.
  4. Hold off on committing to December bonuses until the distribution is modeled against January cash.

Cathcap has been working inside law firms since 2012, and this is the conversation we run with owners every fall. One PI trial firm we worked with moved its profit margin from 16% to 34% of net revenue in seven months, with financial infrastructure that held all year, not just in December (read the case study).

If you can’t answer the questions above for your firm today, October is the right time to find out. What would you want to know before your CPA calls in March?

FAQ

Why is December too late for law firm year-end planning?

Several decisions that affect a law firm’s taxes and cash need lead time: retirement plan setup, equipment placed in service, settlement timing conversations, and distribution modeling. By December, most of those have narrowed to execution or closed, and CPAs are heading into busy season.

When should a law firm meet with its CPA for year-end planning?

October or November. That’s when the CPA still has room to plan, and when there’s still time to act on their advice before December 31.

How does settlement timing affect a PI firm’s taxes?

Most PI firms are cash-basis, so fee income generally counts in the year a settlement clears and is disbursed. The rules are technical, so the firm’s CPA should advise on specific cases, ideally before the check arrives.

What is the deadline to set up a SIMPLE IRA for the current year?

For employers that don’t already have one, a new SIMPLE IRA generally has to be set up by October 1 to cover that year. Exceptions exist for new businesses, so confirm with your CPA.

What should a law firm bring to its year-end CPA meeting?

Current financials, a list of cases likely to settle in Q4, a modeled distribution scenario, open retirement plan questions, and any pending equipment purchases.

Enjoyed this read? Stay in the loop with our latest insights and updates –
subscribe to our newsletter now!